A Fresh Look at I Thessalonians 4
Posted on Thursday, December 21 @ 13:46:49 PST by Samuel Frost |
|
by Samuel Frost This paper was originally written in debate form as a response to Ed Stevens' rapture theory. That debate has been canceled for reasons made known in another article on this site. This paper has been edited, but the body of the material is the same. Stevens' view is representative and, therefore, is the one targeted the most in this paper. Of course, Stevens is a brother of mine in Christ and my attack on his view means nothing of the sort towards the man himself. I trust the readers understand that. Be that as it is, I do consider the rapture theory to be an erratic teaching that leads to an undermining of preterist soteriology.
I. Historical Considerations
Before we get into this, it must be noted that some preterists, like Ed Stevens, do believe in the flying around of Christians in mid-air. He explicitly states that these Christians disappeared off the face of planet earth. It was not just a few Christians, either, but a whole host. In his book (Expectations Demands a Rapture), he briefly mentions Rev. 7 where the saints that "come out of the Great Tribulation" are now seen "in heaven before God". However, this number is "numberless" (7.9). One can almost feel Stevens squirm at this point when reading pages 17-18 with 52-53. Stevens wrote that the number of Christians raptured "might have been less than we think", but then writes, "there was a sizable multitude of Gentiles included in the rapture" (Stevens, 53 Expectations). He does not attempt to solve this problem. Walt Hibbard, an ardent supporter of Stevens' position, argued that there would not have been that many Christians around at that time. Rev. 7 says that there was "a number in which no one could count" and Stevens is aware of this, too. You cannot have it both ways: there was either a little, or a lot, and if there was a lot (in which no one could count, to speak biblically), then you would have to explain another "silence": the silence of the people who witnessed a "sizable multitude" of their population disappear!
Click here to read the entire article
------
Samuel Frost is a columnist for PlanetPreterist.com. Samuel is a MA Pastor of Christ Covenant Church in Tampa Florida. He is the author of Misplaced Hope and Exegetical Essays on the Resurrection of the Dead, both available in the PlanetPreterist bookstore.
View Samuel Frost archives
Note: Opinions presented on PlanetPreterist.com or by PlanetPreterist.com columnists may not necessarily reflect the position of PlanetPreterist.com, or reflect the beliefs, doctrine or theological position of all other preterists. We encourage all readers to first and foremost carefully analyze all articles in the light of God's Word.
|
| |
 |
|
Average Score: 5 Votes: 2
|
|
 |